A recent decision in the Fair Work Commission (FWC) highlights the incredibly fine balance that employers must straddle between ensuring that employees involved in disciplinary processes are afforded procedural fairness and given sufficient information to allow them to meaningfully respond, as well as ensuring that the legal professional privilege attaching to documents created as part of the process is not waived.
Insight
In the decision of Crafti v Cohealth Limited [2025] FWC 3285, a Community Health Worker, Mr Crafti, was employed by a not-for-profit community health organisation, Cohealth. In 2024, a client of Cohealth complained about his interaction with Mr Crafti.
Following the complaint, Cohealth commenced an internal investigation. Mr Crafti objected to the internal investigation process. In light of his objections, Cohealth contacted its lawyers seeking legal advice. Cohealth’s legal representatives in turn engaged a barrister, Mr Fawcett, to conduct an external independent investigation into the complaint to enable the legal representatives to provide legal advice to Cohealth about the matter. In December 2024, Mr Fawcett finalised his report into the allegations and Cohealth’s lawyers provided legal advice to Cohealth based on the findings of the investigation.
On 19 December 2024, Cohealth issued a letter to Mr Crafti outlining the outcome of the investigation. The letter identified which allegations were substantiated, and which were not substantiated. Importantly, the letter also identified the evidentiary basis of the findings. Following this outcome, Mr Crafti was issued with a written warning and placed on a performance improvement plan (PIP). Mr Crafti appealed the decision and argued that there were problems with the conclusions reached by the investigator.
Mr Crafti was ultimately dismissed from his employment in June 2025 for his failure to participate in the PIP and for his failure to improve during the course of the PIP. As part of his claim in the FWC, Mr Crafti sought an order from the FWC to require Cohealth to produce Mr Fawcett’s investigation report. Cohealth refused, asserting client legal privilege and it rejected any assertion that it had waived privilege over the report.
At law, for legal professional privilege to apply, the document, or in this case the investigation report, must first be confidential and it is also necessary to demonstrate that it was created for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice or anticipated litigation.
The focus of the case was as follows:
- Whether the FWC was satisfied that the dominant purpose of the external investigation was a privileged purpose; and
- If yes, whether there was a waiver of the privilege by Cohealth.
If the report was not privileged or if there had been a waiver of the privilege, then the report had to be produced to Mr Crafti.
Was the report subject to legal professional privilege?
In determining the ‘dominant purpose’ of the investigation, the FWC held it was a question of fact, to be determined objectively, having regard to the evidence, the nature of the document and the parties’ submissions. The intention of the author of the document was not considered to be conclusive- rather, it was the character of the document that had to be considered.
The FWC also made clear that to be the ‘dominant’ purpose, it has to be the prevailing, ruling, paramount and most influential purpose, and not merely the primary or substantial purpose.
The FWC considered that in this case, there were multiple purposes for commencing the investigation, namely:
- To provide legal advice about the complaint (the legal advice purpose); and
- To determine whether Mr Crafti had breached Cohealth’s Code of Conduct, and if so, to discipline him in a manner consistent with Cohealth’s procedures (the employment disciplinary purpose).
The FWC considered all of the evidence and held that the lawyers’ dominant purpose for commencing the external investigation was to provide legal advice to Cohealth about the complaint against Mr Crafti. However, in assessing Cohealth’s purpose, the employment disciplinary purpose was the substantial purpose (albeit, not the only purpose). Given this, the FWC determined that the report was not subject to legal professional privilege.
In coming to this decision, the FWC had particular regard to Cohealth’s own evidence, which made it clear that it had decided to engage an external investigator to finalise the investigation on its behalf. The law firm’s letter of engagement and the lawyer’s statement was not sufficient to convince the FWC otherwise.
Was there a waiver of the privilege?
Mr Crafti alleged that even if the report was subject to legal professional privilege, the privilege had been waived. The FWC agreed.
It upheld the proposition that what brings about the waiver is the inconsistency between the conduct of the client and the maintenance of the confidentiality. In this case, Cohealth’s investigation outcome letter notified Mr Crafti of Mr Fawcett’s findings. The letter outlined whether the allegations were substantiated or not, and the evidence relied upon to substantiate the findings, as well as the evidentiary basis upon which Mr Fawcett made such findings, referring to particular statements made by the parties to the investigation.
The FWC held that the disclosure of the evidentiary source of Mr Fawcett’s findings exposed Mr Fawcett’s reasoning beyond that which was necessary. Regardless of the decision about whether or not the report was privileged, there had been a waiver of the privilege. Cohealth was required to produce the report to Mr Crafti.
Why this matters
The decision highlights the fine balance between providing enough information to ensure a procedurally fair disciplinary process, as well as ensuring that the privilege attaching to documents created as part of this process is not waived. Sometimes these objectives are at odds with one another.
In fact, the FWC referred to a recent Full Bench decision (Stephen v Seahill Enterprises [2021] FWCFB 2623), in which the Full Bench said that a procedurally fair workplace investigation initiated by an employer, the outcome of which is intended to be made known to relevant employees in the workplace and which is to lead, where necessary, to corrective or disciplinary action, is generally not for a confidential purpose (and therefore, may not, as a general rule, be protected by the privilege).
The decision also highlights how factually sensitive these kinds of matters are. In another recent FWC decision, Willner v Cooperative Bulk Handling Ltd [2021] FWC 3381, the FWC held that there were two purposes of equal weight for commissioning the investigation – one was for the purposes of providing legal advice, and the second was for the purposes of informing a disciplinary process. Ultimately, the FWC held that the Investigation Protocol (marked ‘Privileged and Confidential’) provided the instructions upon which the law firm and the investigator acted in conducting the investigation, and this made it clear that the purpose of the investigation was to provide legal advice (and therefore, the report was privileged).
How we can help
Decipher Workplace Law are expert workplace investigators, who are available to assist employers embarking on this process.
For more information, visit our website: www.decipherlaw.com.au
This is general advice only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek legal advice regarding your specific circumstances.

