As the school year is set to commence and some Australian parents head back to work, we explore some of the most recent developments in respect of flexible working arrangements.
Insight
In October 2025, we published an article on the Westpac work from home decision. Westpac ultimately decided not to appeal the Fair Work Commission’s (FWC) decision, which held that it was not reasonable for Westpac to refuse the employee’s request to work from home. However, since then, there have been some further developments in this area.
Firstly, the Greens introduced the Fair Work Amendment (Right to Work from Home) Bill 2025 into the Senate in November 2025. The Bill seeks to amend the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) to introduce a statutory right for employees to work from home up to two days per week, regardless of whether or not they have caring responsibilities or other conditions such as being pregnant, having a disability or being 55 or older. The Explanatory Memorandum to the Bill explains that “flexible working arrangements have become an essential feature of modern workplaces and that reasonable access to remote work can improve productivity, inclusion, and work–life balance without undermining business needs. Such flexibility can benefit workers in diverse circumstances regardless of their caring responsibilities”.
If enacted, it would require that before refusing any request by an employee to work from home two days a week, an employer will need to consider what reasonable adjustments could be made to accommodate the request (for example, holding meetings online, using virtual tools for check-ins and team coordination and providing the right IT equipment). In order to refuse such a request, an employer would no longer be able to rely on the “reasonable business grounds” test, but would need to show “the job cannot practically be done” under the proposed hybrid arrangement. The Bill has been referred to the Education and Employment Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 26 March 2026. It will be interesting to see the outcome of this process and we anticipate further commentary about working from home arrangements over the course of the next 12 months.
The Green’s Bill mirrors the sentiment of the Victorian Allan Government, which is also currently considering using Victoria’s equal opportunity laws to create a two day per week work from home entitlement for both public and private sector workers, ahead of the November 2026 state election. However, at this stage, there is no further detail about the proposed laws, or how the Victorian government will overcome any constitutional challenge on the basis it may not have the power to legislate these arrangements.
With this issue remaining front and centre in politics and in the media, there seems to be little chance that the work from home / flexibility debate will abate any time soon.
In addition to the proposed legislative reform, requests for flexible working arrangements remains a live issue before the FWC.
In Gagandeep (Skye) Kaur v G8 Education Trading AS Jellybeans Childcare [2025] FWC 3396 (Jellybeans Childcare), Mrs Kaur, a full-time diploma qualified employee at Jellybeans Childcare, made an application to the FWC seeking to resolve a dispute regarding her flexible working arrangement request.
The background to the matter is that in late 2024, Jellybeans Childcare conducted a statewide review to ensure safety and regulatory compliance within its operations. Following the review, Jellybeans Childcare decided to implement a new rotating roster to ensure that 50% of diploma qualified staff were on site during operating hours. This meant that diploma qualified staff, like Mrs Kaur, had to be transitioned to a new rotating roster.
However, since she commenced in 2023, and as a result of an alleged agreement with management at the time, Mrs Kaur had fixed finishing times ranging from 3:00pm to 3:30pm. Given this, Mrs Kaur made the flexible working arrangement request to ensure that her rostered hours of work would remain as 7:00am to 3:00pm or 3:30pm. The basis for Mrs Kaur’s request was that she had school-aged children who required her care and assistance with after-school activities, homework and the school commute.
Jellybeans Childcare refused her request on ‘reasonable business grounds’. Jellybeans Childcare also submitted that it had provided three different roster options to Mrs Kaur to balance her flexible working arrangement request and the operational requirements of the business. Mrs Kaur rejected all of these proposals and did not submit any alternatives.
The FWC agreed with Jellybeans Childcare that there were reasonable business grounds to deny Mrs Kaur’s request (having regard to the considerations in section 65A(5) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth), and relied on the following reasons:
- child safety;
- legal requirements and compliance;
- team equity and operational fairness (as other employees had also expressed interest in earlier finish times due to family or personal commitments); and
- operational constraints.
The FWC agreed that if Mrs Kaur was granted her flexible working arrangement, then the rosters of other employees would need to be altered to accommodate Mrs Kaur’s roster and there would be an increased cost impact to Jellybeans Childcare (as they’d need additional staff to cover shift times that were later in the day). It would also impact Jellybean Childcare’s ability to ensure minimum staffing levels and child safety. Finally, given that Mrs Kaur’s requested hours would be favourable to other employees with parental responsibilities, it could result in “tension and other workplace issues, arising from equity and fairness”.
Why this matters
The disparate outcomes in both the Westpac and Jellybeans Childcare FWC decisions reinforces the premise that each flexible working arrangement request must be looked at on its own facts, considering the requirements of the specific role, the team and the operations.
While employers generally can’t impose a blanket ban against working from home or other flexible working arrangements, neither can employees expect that their request will always be accommodated.
How we can help
Decipher Workplace Law can guide employers when developing their flexible working policies, and when responding to any work from home, or other flexible work arrangement requests.
For more information, visit our website: www.decipherlaw.com.au
This is general advice only and does not constitute legal advice. Please seek legal advice regarding your specific circumstances.

